Printable View
So you may have seen the carnage that occurred when I tried to do a 3 for 1 trade for some AJ sticks to do some reviews of his work. Unfortunately, due to the extreme generosity of a few BOTLs and a SOTL I now have too many to choose from. So if you were going to pick 4 to review which ones would you choose and why?
http://i1281.photobucket.com/albums/...psilnitwnc.jpg
I am interested to see what you think of the 1844, I've never tried it.
It's dreamy with a little age. Great "budget" stick, IMO.Quote:
Originally Posted by cheaphumidors
http://i495.photobucket.com/albums/r...b/Untitled.png
I like the 1844s
The MoW Side Projects are usually good smokes
and I haven't tried the other 3, so I'm curious. :)
I picked five...cause for someone who loves to read, I don't always do so.
Hahaha dreamy? Do you want to share a milkshake with it and then go to second base with it at the drive-in movies?Quote:
Originally Posted by Tobias Lutz
Second base? You only let me get to first and I had to sit through a Jaws marathon just to get that.Quote:
Originally Posted by cheaphumidors
Well that is because I am a classy lady! The 1844 is clearly a girl about townQuote:
Originally Posted by Browns7213
1844- Because I've never had one
Pinolero - Because I've tried 2 and they both sucked AFAIC and I want to see if I'm the only person on the planet that doesn't understand what all the fuss is about
Diesel Uncut - Because I've never had one
San Lotano The Bull - See reason above
She is a cheap dateQuote:
Originally Posted by cheaphumidors
The Diesel HC is her classier, tastier sister. The one parents say they got right after learning what not to do the first time around. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Tobias Lutz
I vote Diesel Uncut, Diesel Wicked, Pinolero, and San Lotano Oval Maduro.
the best one is mysteriously missing from the lineup...:confused:
Nica Puro, San Latano Oval, 1844 and the Man o War.
1844, San Lotano The Bull, Pinolero, and Diesel Uncut
Great minds man!Quote:
Originally Posted by zeebee
1844, HOTD, Wicked and Uncut.
1844's I've had an enjoyed..and I rather enjoy the HOTD also. Interested in the Wicked and Uncut.
Not particularly a fan of the Bull - I prefer the Connecticut Lotanos. Also, I think the Maduro Pinolero is much better than the regular one.
Ha! Didn't even read the replies before me. My reason is ever so slightly different- I've never had any of them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Billb1960
You noticed that, huh.Quote:
Originally Posted by projectsunfire
New World?Quote:
Originally Posted by projectsunfire
Yeah not much gets by me [emoji6]Quote:
Originally Posted by Browns7213
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
You're missing all the good ones. I think you need another hitQuote:
Originally Posted by Browns7213
Where is the "I do not like this post" button?Quote:
Originally Posted by defetis
First person ever who hates free cigars LOLQuote:
Originally Posted by Browns7213
I'd pick the Nica Libre, 1844, Pinolero and Diesel HOTD. I've tried the Nica Libre, so I can compare what you say with what I remember, and I have the other three and would like to hear more about them.
Oh c'mon, we're just giving you an excuse to buy another humidor...Quote:
Originally Posted by Browns7213
Thank you all for your input! Based on the feedback the review line-up will be:
1844
Diesel Uncut
Pinolero
Wicked
Now to find the time and I still have two blind reviews I need to get to. Whew!
Nice selection. Enjoy and I look forward to your reviews