You hit a lot of the main points - burn, taste, personal score, and so on. I like that it was kinda short and concise.
Rarely do I enjoy reading the 17 page reviews of a single cigar from many of the top reviewing authorities. Too much fluff usually, but I do like to see how some "tastes" align or are translated for more complex cigars or at times where I cannot put my finger on exactly what I'm getting but I know it's somthing.
I would like to know more about your 100-point scoring system.