My Father #4 Lancero Review

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TreySC

Very nice, I always enjoyed your reviews. I like the new rating scale as well, never really understood the number thing when nothing ever really went below the mid 80's

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jordan23

I forgot to add that I dont think your review is lacking due to a "scale" ( I have nothing against them and use them with my personal reviews), but I got plenty of your words.

---

Thanks for saying, this feels better to me too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Laynard

Well, I may have to smoke mine tonight then. I felt underwhelmed by the Le Bijou I had recently, so I'll be heading into this one with high hopes. Thanks for breaking the ice and posting the first review!

---

I don't think this one will disappoint you.

Now, the Le Bijou didn't blow me away the first time either, but now I've smoked a couple more and they've grown on me a lot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mr Jones

Sounds like a good cigar, and this is the best review on the whole site imo!

---

Haha, it didn't last long though. Second best review now :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cardinal

I don't think this one will disappoint you.

Now, the Le Bijou didn't blow me away the first time either, but now I've smoked a couple more and they've grown on me a lot.



Haha, it didn't last long though. Second best review now :(

---

Just got in from smoking the one I had and I must say your review is spot on. Great cigar!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Laynard

Just got in from smoking the one I had and I must say your review is spot on. Great cigar!

---

Cool, glad you liked it. I just spent about 10 minutes price shopping a box :D

Great review and great pictures!

I agree with Jordan, a scale is not needed but I don't think it takes away from a review. For a new guy like me I enjoy reading the descriptions of flavors more than a number. I am more likely to pick up a stick someone describes that fits a flavor profile I enjoy, than arbitrarily trying a 100/100 rated candela because of the score it got. Maybe a number rating on something more objective like construction/burn quality?

Just my :2cents:

Thanks for the review. You could go with

1) Pass
2) Single,
3) 5-Pack,
4) 10 Box
5) 25 Box

as your rating system. Most reviews I read just leave the flavors do the talking which is ok with me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mulley

Great review and great pictures!

I agree with Jordan, a scale is not needed but I don't think it takes away from a review. For a new guy like me I enjoy reading the descriptions of flavors more than a number. I am more likely to pick up a stick someone describes that fits a flavor profile I enjoy, than arbitrarily trying a 100/100 rated candela because of the score it got. Maybe a number rating on something more objective like construction/burn quality?

Just my :2cents:

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DataJockey

Thanks for the review. You could go with

1) Pass
2) Single,
3) 5-Pack,
4) 10 Box
5) 25 Box

as your rating system. Most reviews I read just leave the flavors do the talking which is ok with me.

---

Thanks for the feedback guys. I think I'll go with that pass, single, 5-er, box idea, and try to make note of construction/burn/etc every time.