Worst cigar you've ever smoked

[MattyMatt]

Got the other 3? I love that stick! Want to trade?

They went to my local B&M for Cigars for Warriors.

[Yarddog]

For me, probably the time I lit up a good stogie in the truck for the 90 mile commute home...forget the brand, but it was no doubt something in the $10-12 range...by the time I got to Carpenteria from Goleta, I had to pull over in the McDonald's parking lot and toss...man...never had that happen before!

[D307P]

I know a lot of people like them, but for me it was the DE Kentucky Fire Cured

[Tman]

Tatuaje La Casita Criolla. Tasted like a pencil. I tried 2 out of a 5er. Both times chucked it less than halfway through.

I almost forgot about this one! Yeah, this is the only Tatuaje that I would not buy again.

[Tman]

Brickhouse for me. It tasted like someone rolled up a horse dung.

[jhedrick83]

I almost forgot about this one! Yeah, this is the only Tatuaje that I would not buy again.

I hate to hear this. I love Conn. Broadleaf and I have a 5'er I picked up recently so I can try them, it's resting for a couple weeks more. Maybe I'll like them, who knows.

[Bruck]

I think there's a bimodal distribution on this thread - one is actual worst-ever cigars, and the other is the serious disappointments masquerading as premium cigars. I've had plenty of the latter, but for the former, I would have to say it's a bundle I bought at a little shop in rural Honduras in the 90s. It was something like the equivalent of a few bucks for a bundle of 16 or 20. My tastes were not at all refined at the time, but this one tasted like I was smoking mud. Stuck it out for about half of one, got a splitting headache, and pitched the whole lot of them.

With cigars, you don't always get what you pay for, but you never get what you don't pay for!

[B daddy]

I almost forgot about this one! Yeah, this is the only Tatuaje that I would not buy again.

Damn, I just bought a fiver thinking "it's a tat. How bad could it be?"

[Tman]

Damn, I just bought a fiver thinking "it's a tat. How bad could it be?"

It's not horrible, but it left me scratching my head. I too tasted that "pencil" flavor.

[MattyMatt]

I hate to hear this. I love Conn. Broadleaf and I have a 5'er I picked up recently so I can try them, it's resting for a couple weeks more. Maybe I'll like them, who knows.

Some people like them....you may too. Everyones palate is different. I didn't stumble upon the bad (pencil taste) reviews until after I bought them. And that is what I tasted. It is 100% broadleaf (wrapper, binder, filler)....can anyone chime in if that is the reason for the pencil taste, too much connecticut broadleaf?