Voting Thread for Cigar of the Year!

[jhedrick83]

We came up with one hell of an awesome list of cigars! Now it's time to pick the top dog. The poll contains the top 7 cigars as nominated by the Bums (we are doing 7 instead of 10 due to the number of ties and limits on poll options). If you will please vote on your top 3 choices from this list. That's right, don't pick just one, pick your top 3. We will let this poll run for another 2 weeks so everyone has a chance to vote. Feel free to discuss your choices in the thread. Poll options are in straight alphabetical order to not influence votes.

[Usafvet509]

Of the choices, I could vote for 2.

[jhedrick83]

Of the choices, I could vote for 2.

That's fine as well.

[Rocket Scientologist]

I might get crucified for saying this, but the Anejo is not the greatest cigar ever made, as some might argue. I've smoked several, even bought a box...but there are other cigars that I'd rather smoke, namely the My Father Le Bijou 1922.

[Jaybird]

I might get crucified for saying this, but the Anejo is not the greatest cigar ever made, as some might argue. I've smoked several, even bought a box...but there are other cigars that I'd rather smoke, namely the My Father Le Bijou 1922.

OMG I HATED IT!

Sorry all you AF lovers. That one was a resinous wad of CRAP!

I REALLY do like that CH is the ONLY cigar brand up there 2x..LOL

Carry on!

Cheers
Jay

[AlanS]

In my humble opinion the Jericho Hill is just passable, maybe just not my favorite blend. Be nice

[Old Smokey]

I voted and Jesse thank you again for doing this. That original list was amazing.

[jhedrick83]

I voted and Jesse thank you again for doing this. That original list was amazing.

No problem at all! It's interesting to see what's popular. We need a CB sampler from that original list!

If we end up with a tie, how do you guys want to handle it? A straight run off between what's left or split the title?

[Old Smokey]

No problem at all! It's interesting to see what's popular. We need a CB sampler from that original list!

If we end up with a tie, how do you guys want to handle it? A straight run off between what's left or split the title?

In case of a tie, I vote settling it with knives.

Or, we could just leave it a tie and most everyone will have voted for a winner. Kinda like everyone getting a trophy for playing t-ball. No wait! I'm confused, I'll pass.

[Sticky B]

I found the Jericho Hill and Tat Blacks to be bangin - perhaps not my favs of the year, but def from this list...

2 of them up there I personally disliked and wouldn't care to smoke again (1964 & Le Bijou)

2 of them I haven't tried (LC & Mi Amor)... wait, I might have had a Mi Amor on the drive to NC, if so, it was good

1 was okay, but probably needed more time, the Anejo, haha