So it looks like the Cigar Bum top 3 for 2015 are:

1. Arturo Fuente - Anejo 46
2. Padron - Anniversary 1964 Maduro
3. Tatuaje - Black

Obviously, this is a very unscientific poll but still pretty interesting. We had 95 cigars that were nominated on Cigar Bum, our of our 95 nominations, 4 made the CA top 25 (5 if you count the Padron 1964, we said Maduro, they said natural). The 4 that made the list are:

Bolivar BF (CC)
Laranja
Montecristo Espada
My Father Le Bijou 1922

So, 21 of their top 24 weren't even nominated by the Bums but we did nominate the #1 cigar. So maybe it's not all bought a paid for.