Smoke that caught you by surprise - in a good way

[pdq_wizzard]

Asylum 4x44, RB Genesis and the 1844

[Billb1960]

I've been saying it to anyone who will listen for the past couple of weeks, but the Camacho American Barrel-Aged blew me away. I had very low expectations going into it, and it ended up being one of the best sticks I've ever reviewed. Do yourself a favor and snag a few of these.

Yeah I ordered a 5er and smoked one after about a week and immediately ordered another 5er except now they're backordered!

[Usafvet509]

@defetis , I know a place in Joplin. @Old Smokey 's B&M had em

[defetis]

@defetis , I know a place in Joplin. @Old Smokey 's B&M had em

Good to know thank you. I may have to hit him up

[Shaun]

I've said this on here before, but for me it's the Cuba Libre (original blend, although the "One" is damn good too). Got a few in a sampler a long while back and they bounced around in my humidor for months. I figured they were filler smokes in the sampler.

I finally smoked one and couldn't believe how good it was. Went to buy some more and learned that I can get 5-packs for $5-$7. I buy them regularly now. When I'm smoking them I often find myself smiling about how cheap they are.

[StogieNinja]

This guy:


Kicked around in the bottom of a drawer for several years. Delicate wrapper, but darned if it wasn't an excellent smoke!

[Schatzman]

I've been saying it to anyone who will listen for the past couple of weeks, but the Camacho American Barrel-Aged blew me away. I had very low expectations going into it, and it ended up being one of the best sticks I've ever reviewed. Do yourself a favor and snag a few of these.

When we got them into the shop I smoked one right away and felt the cigar was a massive let down. It lacked the flavor I was expecting a cigar as hyped up like that to have. It was more notes of it and not a full blast like I expected. I would rather smoke the perdomo 12th double aged.

I find it funny how taste is so subjective

[Billb1960]

When we got them into the shop I smoked one right away and felt the cigar was a massive let down. It lacked the flavor I was expecting a cigar as hyped up like that to have. It was more notes of it and not a full blast like I expected. I would rather smoke the perdomo 12th double aged.

I find it funny how taste is so subjective

Kind of how I felt after trying LP No 9

[Shaun]

Kind of how I felt after trying LP No 9

Ditto that. Nice enough smoke but overall my reaction was: "this is what all the fuss is about?"

[Schatzman]

Kind of how I felt after trying LP No 9

Yeah. My argument for the liga is 1 out of 5 is an amazing cigar. I need to smoke a few more of the barrel aged before I give my full verdict. I will say I think LP are a bit over hyped