That's a tough one. I know most cigars get the attention it deserves. It's also a tough subject since some cigars have changed profile over the years. I used to love the Padilla 1932 until they discontinued it. It really hasn't been the same smoke since they discontinued it. I still have boxes of them from 4 years ago and they still stand the test of time.

Some cigars I've personally liked over the years and recently haven't been mentioned recently are: Camacho Diploma, E.P. Carrillo Club 52, Los Blancos Nine, Illusione cg:4, Diamond Crown Maximus #4, La Aurora Preferidos No.2 Maduro, Carlos Torano Exodus, Joya de Nicaragua Antano. I wouldn't be afraid to pick any of them up from my humidor when I want a solid cigar.