Brent, I would recommend grabbing a Pudgy box. They have rested now and some of the sticks are really hitting their prime.
The main difference between the Pudgy and Skinny box (aside from the size) is that Pudgy has 1 of Frank, Drac, Face, Wolf, Mummy and Jason. It has 2 each of Chuck and Tiff. Whereas the Skinny box has 1 each of Frank, Drac, Face, Wolf, Mummy, Jason, Chuck, Tiff, Jekyll, and Hyde. So you do get more variety from the Skinny.
Heck, get one of each. But you may want to let the Skinny box rest for a bit. I know I am. I'll probably wait a couple of months to let a couple of the spicier ones (Jason, Wolf, Mummy) to mellow out a bit for my tastes.