RG What is your size preference?

[herman]

I voted 46-58, primarily because smaller rg sticks are a bit of a rarity at B&Ms around here. When I get packs online they seem to fall in that range as well.

Realistically It comes down to each blend and vitola. I'm likely to try something, normally in a robusto or toro size, and experiment from there.

This is kind of my reason too, but more because of price. The larger RG are usually significantly cheaper. I'm a smaller guy with a thin build and think I look ridiculous when I have a larger cigar in my mouth. In fact my go-to is a 54 gauge and it annoys me sometimes, but with some smaller gauges I kind of feel cheated. I only smoke once a week, so I really enjoy taking 2 hours to smoke a good robusto. I burn through coronas too quickly. Maybe lanceros are the answer.

[Tombstone]

46-58 is where I would normally fall but sometimes I do go for the 60+ If it is a brand new cigar to me I tend to grab a toro or robusto to give it a go.

[Rocket Scientologist]

I prefer 48-52. 54 and up is too big unless it's a box pressed or torpedo.

I'm the same way, 48-52. I'll do larger with box press because they don't feel as big, like a La Antiguedad super toro (7x56).

[DrBob]

I voted 46 to 58 but I mostly enjoy 46 to 52, I have trouble with burn on the fatter vitolas and I like to believe the taste is better with the wrapper to filler ratio on the the medium gauge cigars.