My reviews

[jrfoxx]

Would people rather read reviews of recent production, "everyman" smokes, or do you prefer reviews of well aged, obscure, unusual in some way, etc cigars?

Just trying to see what people actually want reviews on, rather than things I choose to review.

No point in doing them if people arent interested in them.

Thanks,
Sean

I friggin love cigars

[Tombstone]

I like both categories and see value in both of them. If I had to choose I would rather learn about others thoughts on their staple cigars not the unicorns.

[Sir Lancerolot]

Yes.

[cheaphumidors]

I prefer the reviews on the daily/regular sticks

[jrfoxx]

I like both categories and see value in both of them. If I had to choose I would rather learn about others thoughts on their staple cigars not the unicorns.

I've gotten responses of "both" in the same post on CW, and now here, which sounds like a pretty good idea, so will likely go that route starting with the next one.

I friggin love cigars

[jrfoxx]

So, while we're at it, what do people think of this section scoring?

TOTAL SCORES
Appearance/Construction_______ 15************************
Flavor/Strength______15
Finish/Aftertaste____15
Burn _______15******** *
Aroma______5
Smoke volume ______10
Smoke character _____10
Summary_______15
TOTAL______ 100

I made a few minor changes yesterday, and the rest of the "form" that I fill out as I'm smoking, is constantly evolving as things come up with a few cigars, or I think will get the point across better, or to cover a new category that has come up multiple times, etc.

I'm kinda on the fence about a few.

Thanks

I friggin love cigars