Help us settle a debate

[DogRockets]

@Horseshoe and I apparently had a bet that I wouldn't buy any cigars until the 4th of July (after buying the 22 lb box from Heath earlier this year). The stakes were a cigar of the others choice for the winner.

Brent is now claiming I lost the bet.

Here are the facts:
- Previously I had sent some money to someone using paypal with no description in the message area. Essentially a gift if you will.
- Today I received a box of Tat Jekyll in the mail. 9 in the box - not even a full box. It was an apparent bomb from another brother.

Brent claims this was a purchase and he gets a cigar from me. I say I still haven't bought anything.

Time for another famous DogRockets poll - who wins the bet?

[UncleFesterESQ]

The question I have is if the person you sent the PP "gift" to was the same person who "bombed" you with the Tats?

[Horseshoe]

Let's please add to the findings that @DogRockets purchased a total of 2 sticks on Thursday at a B&M. So, not only did he lose the bet by buying the Tats, he also bought 2 sticks at a shop.

The biggest question of all is: WHAT STICK SHOULD I CHOOSE AS MY PAYOFF?

[DogRockets]

The question I have is if the person you sent the PP "gift" to was the same person who "bombed" you with the Tats?

It's hard to say. The paypal went to an email address and the bomber listed a physical return address on the package but there was no note inside indicating an email address.

Essentially there is no way to ever learn this answer I'm afraid.

[UncleFesterESQ]

Let's please add to the findings that @DogRockets purchased a total of 2 sticks on Thursday at a B&M. So, not only did he lose the bet by buying the Tats, he also bought 2 sticks at a shop.

The biggest question of all is: WHAT STICK SHOULD I CHOOSE AS MY PAYOFF?

Hmmm... Well, if you go into a B&M you are obligated to buy at least one stick... this would be outside of the bet IMHO. But 2 sticks???? Hmmmm.... Still waiting for a reply to my original question.

[UncleFesterESQ]

It's hard to say. The paypal went to an email address and the bomber listed a physical return address on the package but there was no note inside indicating an email address.

Essentially there is no way to ever learn this answer I'm afraid.

Sounds like Tom Brady's deflategate story going on here. Horseshoe wins!!!

[OldSkoolTarHeel]

I'm with @Horseshoe on this 1,000,000%. Even without the "random bomb" of 9 Jekylls (is anybody buying his argument here), you bought TWO cigars at a B&M.

PAY UP SUCKA!!!

[Horseshoe]

It's hard to say. The paypal went to an email address and the bomber listed a physical return address on the package but there was no note inside indicating an email address.

Essentially there is no way to ever learn this answer I'm afraid.

What if I were to show you a screen shot of said transaction where it listed the seller and BUYER? Would this be sufficient evidence to show @DogRockets did in fact knowingly purchase cigars, thus losing the bet?

[DogRockets]

Hmmm... Well, if you go into a B&M you are obligated to buy at least one stick... this would be outside of the bet IMHO. But 2 sticks???? Hmmmm.... Still waiting for a reply to my original question.

I'm with @Horseshoe on this 1,000,000%. Even without the "random bomb" of 9 Jekylls (is anybody buying his argument here), you bought TWO cigars at a B&M.

PAY UP SUCKA!!!

@Horseshoe has left out a key fact - B&M purchases were exempted from the bet - so it still seems like I win

[Tgs679]

Let's please add to the findings that @DogRockets purchased a total of 2 sticks on Thursday at a B&M. So, not only did he lose the bet by buying the Tats, he also bought 2 sticks at a shop.

The biggest question of all is: WHAT STICK SHOULD I CHOOSE AS MY PAYOFF?

A Jekyll