I would consider myself a My Father Whore!
The only one I haven't smoked yet is the JJ (but I have one sitting in the humi).
The only one I didn't care for was the Tobac Baez. I think that's because I smoked it in my infancy (I'm a toddler now ). Probably didn't allow it to rest and didn't know how to appreciate a milder cigar then.
If I had to give them an order of preference, it would go a little something like this...

Le Bijou
Jamie Garcia Reserva Especial
Blue label
El Centurion
Cuban Classic
Le Antiguidad
Flor de las Antillas
Any of the La Rebola blends
La Dueña
My Father CT (I have to revisit this)

There may be a few that I haven't tried, but I don't think it's many! Like the Cedros line that was mentioned.
I prefer anything from a petite Robusto to a toro, but I'm willing to try the smaller RG too (I'm sitting on a lancero that I'm dying to try, but want to give it the time & attention it deserves; @Cardinal )!