Anyone else get stuck into brand "loyalty"?

[jhedrick83]

I try to branch out as much as I can but there are times when I just want a known quantity. For example, if it's been a long day and I'm just exhausted, I don't want to necessarily smoke something new to me as I like to try and give new cigars as fair a shake as I can. I also want to pick something out that I know I will like and what to expect construction wise.

[Brimy]

I used to do the opposite... I had brand prejudice and found myself not trying cigars by a certain brand because the first one I smoked from them didn't appeal to me. I just this year started making a concentrated effort to break out of this pattern.

But I do have a problem saying no to any AJ Fernandez stick. I LOVE him so I end up smoking things (like a Connecticut wrapper) that I normally wouldn't simply because it has his name on it.

Glad you figured it out!
But it's also easy to understand one's hesitation to explore when you know you're going to get something good from a particular brand. And it's very easy to avoid a brand after a bad experience (Ghurka).

[Usafvet509]

I have to go with Kayla on that, there are brands I've avoided after a lackluster stick or 2. Then there are the brands where I havent had a SINGLE stick I've liked at all.
As for loyalty, absolutely, there are brands that I would be happy to smoke exclusively, LGC, EP Carrillo and CAO are perfect examples. My status as a General whore is pretty well known here
All things said, I love getting to smoke a variety of cigars still. I am delighted to find new brands by exploration. I have in recent months surrendered the notion that I preferred Honduran leaf above all, LFD and AJF are to thank for that. That's an awesome thread, by the way. RG to you

[Bruck]

No. I mean yes. Whatever

Not brand loyalty so much as, dang, do I really want to learn yet another brand? But for expeditionary purposes, I usually try to find something I haven't tried before in every order.

I do have a soft spot for CLE as I have a friend who works for them, and Graycliff as I've toured their "factory" and took a rollng lesson there.

[Haebar]

I've had an affair with CAO cigars lately, although my humidors are now filled to the brim and I have to stop. Had one of the Brazilias about a year ago that really impressed me and a few days later an Italia and like it too. Both of those were aged about 3-4 years. When I tried a new one lately, it was kind of edgy; guess I'll let those rest for another year or so.

[droy1958]

For quite a long time I stuck with a few brands, likely four or five, and buying boxes, usually of more or less the same sizes in those brands. Smoking other brands, sizes in lesser numbers.After finding and joining Cigarbum tho still buying boxes, have smoked a much wider variety of cigars. Never did an inventory or count of cigars on hand prior to January first 2015. Determined to reduce the number on hand to no more than sixty cigars. Number on hand right now is closer to where it was on Jan 1st, 2015.
*
*
Know this isn't really an answer to the question. But starting to think about this and will likely update after I've gotten a bit of sleep.

I'm thinking you're going to go with My Father/ Pepin if you're down to one brand....

[Nature]

Not so much brand loyal, but tend to stick with lines where I have had good experiences and know I will probably enjoy again. Anything DPG / My Father come to mind here. Crowned Heads and LFD fall into this category for me as well. Some brands I tend to pass over becauuse I may have had a few I didn't enjoy as much; Rocky Patel might fall into this category, even though I have had a few that were fine. Then there is just plain reputation, like Gurkha. I am sure there are some great cigars with this name; but too many to pan through that disappoint in order to find that fleck of gold.

[allusred]

I'm thinking you're going to go with My Father/ Pepin if you're down to one brand....

Just spotted this post.
My first instinct was to congratulate you your accurate guess...
but, realize yo would only have to've asked Smokin Monkey to get that correct.
Even that shy, but ever so cute Girlfriend of his, whom I'm quite certain you've
found to be a very warm and affectionate companion to spend some (night) time with
would've said My Father/Pepin cigars.
Heck, even I was able to arrive at that same conclusion...
give me a bit more time and I maybe able to remember what that was.

[Kidvegas]

I'm absolutely stuck on certain companies and certain rollers. Cigars to me is not a cheap hobby, although an extremely satisfying one. With that being said at one time i was all over the place with what i was smoking, and alot of times i spent hard earned money on a gar to find myself not enjoying or completely disliking the stick.
I stil try different stuff ounce in a while, but for sure i only by the stuff i truley dig in bulk.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[droy1958]

Just spotted this post.
My first instinct was to congratulate you your accurate guess...
but, realize yo would only have to've asked Smokin Monkey to get that correct.
Even that shy, but ever so cute Girlfriend of his, whom I'm quite certain you've
found to be a very warm and affectionate companion to spend some (night) time with
would've said My Father/Pepin cigars.
Heck, even I was able to arrive at that same conclusion...
give me a bit more time and I maybe able to remember what that was.

Errrr.... I forgot what the question was.....😁