that one cigar that live up to the hype and oh so much more

[Billb1960]

Have to say the Anejo Shark was an amazing cigar. The only thing disappointing about it is how hard it is to get more!

[Horsefeathers]

The Illusione Epernay. Universally good reviews, and I was still surprised at how good it was. One of my favorite sticks.

[gordo1473]

Try the illusione singulare very good cigar

[DLtoker]

Sharks and VSG all day long, indeed. Siglo VI is off the charts, too.

[Tobias Lutz]

Davidoff Nicaragua (preferably the robusto)

[B daddy]

RoMa Craft CroMagnon and Aquitaine both.

[DogRockets]

Padron 1926 Natural and Jericho Hill by Crowned Heads

The one I was just gifted and HOPE lives up to the hype is Las Calaveras by Crowned Heads

[Myfirstandlastname]

The JGRE 11 I smoked recently was definitely as good as described... In addition, I found the Oliva SG-01 from their world tour sampler to be phenomenal as well.

[Cardinal]

Anejo 46.

[Tman]

I agree with Ashton VSG, Los Blanco Nine, and Illusions Epernay. I think Undercrown deserves a spot too. You can find them at pretty affordable price if you know where to look.