LP 9s

Most Padrons I've had (good flavor, impeccable construction, but one note)

My first Cuban cigar (because I expected the heavens to open and angels to sing to me. )

Those immediately come to mind. I learned to a.) mostly stick to what I think I'll like based on blender, country origin, wrapper type, company and b.) to not have expectations with a new cigar, as hard as that may be.