Alright, here is the finally tally:

For me:
Nub Dub - 5 cigars - $18.94 (x2)
Nub Dub - 5 cigars - $17.66 (x2)
La Perla Habana Black Pearl Belicoso - box of 20 - $31
CI Legends by Perdomo - box of 20 - $37
La Perla Habana Black Pearl Belicoso - 5 cigars - $9
La Duena No 5 - 2 cigars - $4 (x2)

For my father-in-law:
Mark Twain - 3 cigars - $2 (x3)
Mark Train - 5 pack - $7
Don Smith - bundle of 20 cigars - $10

Shipping $14.70

Total $195.90

Hey, I kept my order under $200!!!!!!!