I am liking the guillotine cut first, then the punch. My lighter has a pop out punch cutter so I'm able to carry both easily.
Xikar punch is the first thing i reach for.
It's a Guillotine or V for me depending on the cigar, and mood.
"Hate, it has caused a lot of problems in the world, but has not solved one yet."
― Maya Angelou
Go Vols!
Right now, my Xikar VX gun-metal cutter rules the world. I got one for Christmas after I lost my Xi1, so I've been down to that and a CC Perfect cutter. Even after I break down and buy a new Xi1, I'll probably stick with the the v-cut for awhile.
If I didn't have a Cuban Crafters Perfect cutter, would probably punch or V-cut. But the Perfect cutter cuts just the right amount.